Developing NICU Competencies

Just a few thoughts. Those developing the NICU competency will benefit from a period of reflective thinking to avoid the tendency to look for something already done or a cookbook, though guidelines can clearly guide and inform our own key learnings and formalized competencies. My dear friend and SLP colleague, Bob Beecher, from Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin used to say: “Cookbooks are made for cooking not for eating…use them wisely.”

SLPs mentoring new colleagues can develop very meaningful mentorship plans and identify objective SLP clinical skills for “check off” through careful reflection and application of current literature. This includes drawing from their own mentorship in the past (what worked, what was missing), or if you were not fortunate to have a mentor and came from the ground up alone, like I did in 1985 – what you now know is essential). Consider the current mentorship process in place (and feedback from recent staff mentored). Compile current literature that is essential as a foundation for NICU practice. Throughout the mentoring, it is critical to reflect that being part of an NICU is a journey, not a destination. Both the NICU’s evolution from a medical and technology perspective, as well as our own need to continue learning and growing in this rapidly changing clinical environment, are essential to an NICU practice that thrives and does so with respect and professional integrity.

Focus on providing the mentee with guided participation with and then assessing objectively (while supervised) their competency related to verbalizing and/or demonstrating the underpinnings of NICU practice during both evaluations and treatments. Even today these are rarely discussed in graduate school), and include: neuroprotection, medical co-morbdities and current technologies and their typical impact on feeding/swallowing, developmental progression of the dynamic systems (postural , state, oral-sensory-motor, respiratory, GI) that underlie feeding/swallowing for sick term infants versus preterm infants, guidelines for referral to ST (who, when, why, how to advocate), readiness factors for PO feeding and how SLP can support the progression to PO feeding (as co-morbidities permit), parameters for physiologic stability and indications of decompensation as well as how to avert and/or respond, the components of evaluation and completing a differential utilizing a wide range of data, explaining one’s differential to others (MD versus RN versus the family), instrumental assessment of swallowing physiology (why, when, how, potential intervention strategies and their benefits/risks), documenting to assist the team via your impression and plan versus only checking off boxes, strategies to support safety and their evidence-base (co-regulated pacing, resting, positioning, swaddling, state modulation, nipple selection), infant communication (signs of stress versus stability, signs of disengagement versus engagement), NICU equipment (what, why, application to SLP practice, progression of respiratory support, lines and their risks), team relationships (learning from other team members, bringing the evidence-base, difficult but respectful conversations, controversies due to the emerging evidence-base, supporting families), breastfeeding (physiology and relationship to bottle feeding, how to support as an SLP), common medications and potential impact of PO feeding. I am sure I am leaving something out but this is hopefully a start.

The depth and complexity of our work in the NICU, and the potential for these often fragile infants to decompensate, demand that both mentorship and competency assessment be carefully structured and supported. Our profession and our families deserve no less.

I hope this is helpful.
Catherine

PO Feeding on NCPAP and/or HFNC: The Dilemma

This is a practice dilemma for all NICU SLPs. The pressure to get infants out of the NICU often drives care decisions, especially when it comes to PO feeding.

Many neonatologists incorrectly assume that there is a window within which our preterms must “experience” PO feeding or they will “miss that critical window and never learn”. So, despite co-morbidities and often respiratory needs that are paramount, infants are being asked to feed. That well-intentioned paradigm is based on writings from Gesell back in the 60s that talked about a “critical window” for learning to eat. Those times were different in many ways as was the population being described. Early intervention now in NICUs to support readiness, neonatal care that is neuro-protective and promotes positive overcomes, and recognition of safety issues inherent in the complex task of PO feeding even when weaned from CPAP and HFNC clearly call for reconsideration of that paradigm, which, perhaps to a large part, underlies the thinking that leads to “pushing PO” and orders to PO on CPAP and HFNC. Many of our former preterms do indeed learn to feed orally at later ages, once weaned, and from my experience do so with much less stress and much more safely.

Advocating for safety for these infants is a critical one for SLPs in the NICU and PICU. Current NICU technology has advanced to the point that more infants are surviving and yet many are requiring extended periods of CPAP and HFNC. Many extremely preterm infants in our NICU with CLD at post-term (41 weeks PMA +) remain dependent on CPAP or HFNC. MY NICU team has had good collaborative conversations about the benefits of ST being involved to maintain a positive oral-sensory environment, promoting the oral-sensory-motor components that are the underpinnings for future PO feeding, beginning early to foreshadow for parents the swallowing, breathing and postural skills needed, and helping families also support those components, versus attempting PO feeding when the infant clearly is struggling with respiratory stability. Clearly, medical co-morbidities predispose an infant in the NICU to PO feeding problems. Multiple papers have studied that. Those infants with the greatest respiratory comorbidities, often those born < 28 weeks’ gestation and BW < 1000 grams, are most likely to require CPAP and/or HFNC at those post-menstrual ages when PO feeding is often attempted. Sick newborns may also present similar issues, secondary to their co-morbidities.

If the infant has such respiratory needs that he requires CPAP, or a HFNC, one must ask if PO feeding is really a priority for that infant at that time. The ability to reconfigure the pharynx from a respiratory tract and back to an alimentary tract with precise timing and coordination surrounding each swallow is a concern. When we look objectively in radiology during an instrumental assessment of swallowing physiology, even infants with CLD stable on RA have altered or impaired swallowing physiology as a direct result of their CLD. The bolus mis-direction and resulting aspiration we often observe is typically silent. In the adult population in the most recent information I have seen (Garon et al, 2009 Journal of Neuroscience Nursing) reported that of 2000 adults studied with a variety of co-morbid conditions, including COPD, 54.5% of those who aspirated did so silently. The data I have collected thus far for NICU infants suggests strongly to me that even the data from Arvedson et al in 1994 likely underestimated the tendency for infants to silently aspirate. In addition, her study population was not only less involved from a respiratory perspective back in 1994 than the population we see today, but it also was a population composed of not just infants. The need for an “urgent breath” often can predispose an infant with increased work of breathing to silently mis-direct the bolus into the airway during the swallow. The ability of the infant to close the glottis against the driving force of the respiratory support, while breathing with increased effort or with an increased respiratory rate, which effectively creates air hunger, and yet still maintain glottic closure throughout the duration of the swallow, would likely be precarious. Given the infant’s likelihood of baseline tachypnea and increased WOB, the dynamic adjustments of the airway surrounding the swallow are likely to be disrupted, and create uncoupling of swallowing and breathing. Without objective data on the impact of CPAP or HFNC on swallowing physiology we cannot conclude that feeding under these conditions is “safe”. Indeed, infants for whom we do not necessarily capture aspiration during a dynamic swallow study may indeed show alterations in swallowing physiology that may indeed predispose them to aspiration under “the right conditions” during PO feeding (changes in nipple flow, changes in position, changes in respiratory support for example) so it isn’t even just about aspiration but the potential impact of CPAP and HFNC on swallowing physiology. The fact that the infants “eat” and “are fed” and “transferred volume” does not equate to “safe feeding”.

We must of course consider the physiologic stress likely to occur when the infant experiences “feeding” when they still require NCPAP and or HFNC. It is highly possible the stress of trying to breathe and coordinate a swallow may lay down neural pathways that move the infant away from wanting to eat, by wiring those sensory-motor pathways that lead to current and/or future maladaptive feeding behaviors. We know that studies looking at stress in preterms have shown an association with adverse changes in brain structure on MRIs.

In the NICU seminars I teach, this body of evidence and our dilemma are always part of our problem-solving discussions. I am fortunate after 32 years in the NICU to be part of a team that is looking beyond “getting them to eat” and looking to partner with ST to guide practice while the evidence-base is emerging. NICU SLPs are in a key role to dialogue, problem-solve and focus on safety and neuroprotection as essential part of this practice issue which confronts every neonatal team.

Jim Coyle has said: “There is one rule of thumb: there is no single parameter that qualifies or disqualifies a patient for anything or that confirms or refutes risk in and of itself. It is the combination of parameters that the clinician uses to estimate risk and to form a diagnostic impression and complete a differential. That is what we teach students and trained clinicians should be emphasizing. Grab your water bottle and go for a 2-3-mile run. After 15 minutes when at your aerobic steady state and RR is up, try to take a drink of water and observe what you need to do to orchestrate the whole thing. Yet you are healthy and mature and not recovering from respiratory issues. Very illuminating.”

The dialogue needs to continue and we need measures of oral feeding that go beyond intake, and methods of assessment that capture critical variables, including objective assessment of physiology.

I hope this is helpful.

Catherine

Research Corner: High Flow Cannulae

Article Review

Leder SB, Siner JM, Bizzarro MJ, McGinley BM, Lefton-Greif MA.

Oral alimentation in neonatal and adult populations requiring high-flow oxygen via nasal cannula. Dysphagia 2016, 31;154-159.

article available through Google Scholar

I am quite concerned by the conclusions of Leder et al regarding safety of oral feeding for preterm infants requiring CPAP.

Advocating for safety for these infants is a critical one for SLPs in the NICU and PICU. Current NICU technology has advanced to the point that more infants are surviving and yet many are requiring extended periods of CPAP and HFNC. Many extremely preterm infants in our NICU with CLD at post-term (41 weeks PMA +) remain dependent on CPAP or HFNC. Our team has had good collaborative conversations about the benefits of ST being involved to maintain a positive oral-sensory environment, promoting the oral-sensory-motor components that are the underpinning’s for future PO feeding, beginning early to foreshadow for parents the swallowing, breathing and postural skills needed, and helping families also support those components, versus attempting PO feeding when the infant clearly is struggling with respiratory stability. Clearly, medical co-morbidities predispose an infant in the NICU to PO feeding problems. Multiple papers have studied that. Those infants with the greatest respiratory co-morbidities, often those born < 28 weeks’ gestation and BW < 1000 grams, are most likely to require CPAP and/or HFNC at those post-menstrual ages when PO feeding is often attempted. Sick newborns may also present similar issues. Secondary to their co-morbidities.

If the infant has such respiratory needs that he requires CPAP, or a HFNC, one must ask if PO feeding is really a priority for that infant at that time. The ability to reconfigure the pharynx from a respiratory tract and back to an alimentary tract with precise timing and coordination surrounding each swallow is a concern. When we look objectively in radiology during an instrumental assessment of swallowing physiology, even infants with CLD stable on RA have altered or impaired swallowing physiology as a direct result of their CLD. The bolus mis-direction and resulting aspiration we often observe is typically silent. This is quite concerning given the conclusion from Leder et al’s study does not even mention this possibility. In the adult population in the most recent information I have seen (Garon et al, 2009 Journal of Neuroscience Nursing) reported that of 2000 adults studied with a variety of co-morbid conditions, including COPD, 54.5% of those who aspirated did so silently. Should the potential for silent aspiration not at least be mentioned? The data I have collected thus far for NICU infants suggests strongly to me that even the data from Arvedson et al in 1994 likely underestimated the tendency for infants to silently aspirate. In addition, her study population was not only less involved from a respiratory perspective back in 1994 than the population we see today, but it also was a population composed of not just infants. The need for an “urgent breath” often can predispose an infant with increased work of breathing to silently mis-direct the bolus into the airway during the swallow. The ability of the infant to close the glottis against the driving force of the respiratory support, while breathing with increased effort or with an increased respiratory rate, which effectively creates air hunger, and yet still maintain glottic closure throughout the duration of the swallow, would likely be precarious. Given the infant’s likelihood of baseline tachypnea and increased WOB, the dynamic adjustments of the airway surrounding the swallow are likely to be disrupted, and create uncoupling of swallowing and breathing. Without objective data on the impact of CPAP or HFNC on swallowing physiology we cannot conclude that feeding under these conditions is “safe”. Indeed, infants for whom we do not necessarily capture aspiration during a dynamic swallow study may indeed show alterations in swallowing physiology that may indeed predispose them to aspiration under “the right conditions” during PO feeding (changes in nipple flow, changes in position, changes in respiratory support for example) so it isn’t even just about aspiration but the potential impact of CPAP and HFNC on swallowing physiology. The fact that the infants “ate” and “were fed” and “transferred volume” does not equate to “safe feeding”. Leder et al’s conclusions don’t unfortunately take this into account.

We must of course consider as well the physiologic stress likely to occur when the infant experiences “feeding” under such circumstances. It is highly possible the stress of trying to breathe and coordinate a swallow may actually lay down neural pathways that move the infant away from wanting to eat, by wiring those sensory-motor pathways that lead to current and/or future maladaptive feeding behaviors. We know that studies looking at stress in preterms have shown an association with adverse changes in brain structure on MRIs.

My colleague, Dr. Suzanne Thoyre, a neonatal nurse feeding researcher, raised some excellent questions about the study design some of which I will try to share in my own words, as she is not a part of our list serve

What did Leder et al deem for inclusion criteria that would be “stable respiratory status” and “Cardio-respiratory stability”? Typically, infants requiring CPAP or HFNC have both increased WOB and increased RR. RR may appear artificially low when rates are captured by a monitor for example that does not sense shallow rapid breaths. Was WOB a consideration? This is a key component of infant clinical assessment of breathing in preparation for attempting as well as during PO feeding. Excessive WOB even in the presence of a less elevated RR can alter timing of swallowing and breathing and often lead to silent bolus mis-direction in the NICU population, much as it might in adults with respiratory work. It is common that infants requiring even low flow oxygen cannot feed without a co-occurring increase in their work of breathing. Two of my OT colleagues in NICUs out East who each observed MD-directed RNs feeding infants on CPAP and HFNC reported seeing significant increase in WOB, RR and signs of behavioral stress.

How was successful oral feeding measured? Did they collect physiologic and behavioral data that demonstrated no indicators of stress, change in oxygen saturation, change in HR, change in respiratory status? The tool they used to measure this needs to be provided. If the feeder simply filled out a checklist, it would be important to know how those observers were trained, how all of these parameters were described and what definitions were used for change in these parameters.
Are the infants in the study on CPAP and HFNC truly being PO fed at 32 weeks PMA? Or is the term “corrected GA” being used incorrectly? I ask because typically even healthy preterms without co-morbidities stable in RA are not being fed PO in most NICUs, with some rare exception. This needs clarification and perhaps makes the conclusions even more concerning.

Unfortunately, Leder et al’s paper will reinforce an incorrect not uncommon assumption. Many neonatologists incorrectly assume that there is a window within which our preterms must “experience” PO feeding or they will “miss that critical window and never learn”. So despite co-morbidities and often respiratory needs that are paramount, infants are being asked to feed. That well-intentioned paradigm is based on writings from Gesell back in the 60s that talked about a “critical window” for learning to eat. Those times were different in many ways as was the population being described. Early intervention now in NICUs to support readiness, neonatal care that is neuro-protective and promotes positive overcomes, and recognition of safety issues inherent in the complex task of PO feeding even when weaned from CPAP and HFNC clearly call for reconsideration of that paradigm, which, perhaps to a large part, underlies the thinking that leads to “pushing PO” and orders to PO on CPAP and HFNC. Many of our former preterms do learn to feed orally at later ages, once weaned, and from my experience do so with much less stress and much more safely.

The dialogue needs to continue and we need measures of oral feeding that go beyond intake, and methods of assessment that actually capture critical variables, including objective assessment of physiology.

I hope this is helpful.

Research Corner: Reflection in the NICU

Thoyre, S., Park, J., Pados, B., & Hubbard, C. (2013). Developing a co-regulated, cue-based feeding practice: The critical role of assessment and reflection. Journal of Neonatal Nursing, 19(4), 139-148.

 

Those of you who practice in the NICU will enjoy this article by my colleague, Suzanne Thoyre PhD RN, on the use of reflection during the assessment of feeding in the NICU. Together we developed the Early Feeding Skills Assessment Tool (EFS) which is referenced at the end of this article.  The focus herein is viewing an assessment as providing opportunities for infant communication.

I believe that when we conceptualize feeding as a relationship–based experience, we then see our role during feeding as dynamically attending to infant communication from moment to moment, responding contingently to support physiologic and behavioral stability, and therefore averting stress for the infant. This then supports neuroprotection, which is our ultimate goal with both preterm and sick newborns in intensive care. Dr. Thoyre does a wonderful job capturing this concept. Because it is written by an NICU RNs, it is information that will likely be helpful to you in your conversations about cue-based feeding with your nursing colleagues.

“The feeder maintains a goal to optimize the feeding through assessment of infant cues. Assessment skills are deepened through a process of focused observation and reflection on what is being learned (from the infant).  The feeder uses all modalities available to observe and interpret infant communication (both physiologic and behavioral), and reflects on the meaning of the infant’s cues. Cue-based feeding is therefore more than learning to respond to infant distress; it is also learning from the infant how to anticipate what they will need and providing appropriate support so they can have as successful a feeding experience as is possible. Through this process, the feeder supports and strengthens the infant’s efforts, and respects and protects their limits. Assessment of the skills an infant brings to the feeding is essential if we are to provide feeding support that meets the infant’s needs.

Catherine

Shaker ASHA Sphere Blog

Shaker ASHA Sphere Blog: 5 Things You

Need to Know About Working in the

Neonatal Intensive Care Unit

June 2, 2015 by Catherine Shaker, MS/CCC-SLP, BCS-S

Screen Shot 2015-06-05 at 1.17.19 PM

If you answered yes to any of the questions in my first post about wanting to work with acute care infants, then read this follow-up!

  1. The NICU is an intensive care unit: Infants in the NICU are critically ill or were in the recent past. These most fragile patients can               become physiologically unstable at any time—and it might happen during your therapy. The emotional roller coaster of NICU leaves families fragile, too.
  2. It’s not easy to practice in the NICU environment: Quick and constant losses and triumphs cause emotions to run high. An infant’s status can change at any time. Caregivers are highly skilled and passionate, which sometimes leads to strong opinions and respectful disagreements. The SLP needs to thoughtfully collaborate, yet at times take a stand.
  3. The NICU SLP requires advanced practice skills: It’s not just knowing what to do, but what not to do. We often support feeding/swallowing, so the risk for compromising an infant’s airway is significant. Essential skills include solid critical reflective thinking, the ability to complete a differential, and broad, multi-system knowledge about preterm development and swallowing/feeding. Your preparation should include solid experience with the birth-to-3 patients, as well as continuing education, mentorship and guided participation with many infants in both the newborn nursery and the NICU. The NICU is too demanding to be an initial independent placement after graduate school.
  4. The NICU evidence base is rapidly evolving: Read, read, read as much professional neonatal literature as possible. Sources are not just within our field but also in medical, nursing and OT/PT journals. Our role is not only to understand the evidence base, but to bring it to the NICU team. Neonatologists and neonatal nurses will ask “why?” and we must be able to discuss the research-based evidence along with our clinical wisdom: For example, if you recommend changing from “volume-driven” to “infant-guided” feeding.
  5. The NICU is rewarding: After almost 30 years working full time in the NICU, not a day goes by that I don’t learn something, make a difference in an infant’s life or experience the joy of a grateful “thank you!” from a family. The appreciation from nurses and neonatologists when an infant can now feed safely and, therefore, go home, makes your day. With such rewards, however, comes great responsibility. In our hands lies the potential to influence parent-infant relationships through positive neuro-protective feeding experiences that wire the brain toward feeding and build future connections.

If you are thinking about moving into NICU practice, you will find lots of information on my website. Stay tuned for more tips to guide your journey!
 Catherine S. Shaker, MS, CCC-SLP, BCS-S, works in acute care/inpatient pediatrics at Florida Hospital for Children in Orlando. She specializes in NICU services and has published in this practice area. She offers seminars on a variety of neonatal/pediatric swallowing/feeding topics across the country. Follow her at http://www.Shaker4SwallowingandFeeding.com or email her at pediatricseminars@gmail.com. 

 

I am an official blogger for ASHA regarding infant feeding and swallowing and acute care pediatrics. Follow me there too!
 

Shaker Webinar on Passy-Muir Valve in the NICU to Optimize Swallowing and Feeding

Shaker Webinar on Passy-Muir Valve in the NICU to Optimize Swallowing and Feeding 

This webinar will highlight the key components of Passy-Muir Valve use in the Neonatal Intensive Unit (NICU) for swallowing and feeding. Limited information is available in the literature about application of the valve in this setting. The presenters will describe their journey, share their key clinical leanings and the positive response in their NICU. The fragile nature of these patients, combined with limited knowledge on the part of medical/nursing staff regarding the benefits of the Passy-Muir Valve, require a thoughtful and team-oriented approach. The clinical benefits for using the valve for swallowing and feeding will be reviewed. Functional changes during instrumental assessments with the valve will be highlighted.

Go to www.passy-muir.com for all the details and to view

Shaker Publication on moving away from volume-driven feeding

“Feed Me Only When I’m Cueing: Moving Away From a Volume-Driven Culture in the NICU” published in the May-June 2012 issue of Neonatal Intensive Care –The Journal of Perinatology-Neonatology.

Abstract: The adverse feeding  outcomes of NICU graduates and their enduring feeding problems suggest a need  to critically look at  “the culture of feeding” in the NICU. It is a pivotal factor in how the preterm experiences feeding , how parents develop their working model of the feeding  relationship, and how the NICU  team communicates about,  and attempts to support,  feeding skills needed for discharge to home. These cultural underpinnings can affect caregiving, both adversely and positively, and, therefore, the emergence of safe and successful feeding and  swallowing.  An “infant-driven” culture of feeding (Ludwig & Waitzman, 2007) embraces the infant as a co-regulatory partner. A more traditional “volume-driven” feeding culture focuses on emptying  the bottle. An Infant-driven culture is suggested as essential for a true cue-based feeding approach, which optimally supports the preterm infant’s developmental strivings and long-term well-being.

Together, we can help change the culture of feeding in the NICU.

Catherine

 

 

Research Corner: Oral feeding skills in preterm infants

The tool described, developed by a well-respected NICU researcher, Chantal Lau, used a subject population of “healthy” preterms. Healthy preterms are those without co-morbidities, and defined in her paper as “feeders and growers” with a primary diagnosis of prematurity — clinically stable, demonstrating signs of  “immature” systems, e.g., immature lung function, that resolved with maturation. These are NICU infants for whom therapy is not typically consulted, as they tend to progress with maturation, precisely because they do not have co-morbidities.

Excluded from her study population where infants with co-morbidities, including respiratory (Chronic Lung Disease, vent course, respiratory sequelae secondary to being  born at < 28 weeks gestation), GI, airway, neuro, lower BW). These co-morbidities have been shown to significantly increase the transition time to full PO feedings in NICU infants and also place these infants risk for adverse feeding outcomes through the toddler years and often beyond. See: Kirk et al (2006)” Risk factors for poor feeding progression in preterm infants” Journal of Investigative Medicine 54-s98; Jadcherla et al (2010) “Impact of prematurity and co-morbidities on feeding milestones in neonates: A retrospective study” JPerinatology 30:201-208.

The tool described in Lau’s article does not have applicability to the NICU population we see as NICU SLPs, as it was not studied with that population. We can profile relative risk for feeding problems in the NICU population we see and assign a relative number value for risk through use of the NMI (Neonatal Medical Index). See Shaker & Woida (2007) ‘An evidence-based approach to nipple feeding in the NICU: Nurse autonomy, developmental support and teamwork” Neonatal Network 26:77-83. Lau’s tool is not appropriate for the typical NICU infants on our caseloads.

Indeed, the focus of the tool Lau describes is on volume transfer and intake, historically a key measure of feeding success. However, many NICUs are witnessing, and in some NICUs SLPs are leading, a movement away from volume-driven feedings in the NICU (numbers, intake) to “infant-driven feeding” (quality of the feeding, positive experience, during which  the feeder relies on the infant’s feedback from  moment to moment to guide co-regulated responses). Hopefully in your NICU a culture change is underway.